10 March 2004 · Planning Committee
The Courtyard Ltd, The Courtyard Office, Arbory Street, Castletown, Isle Of Man, IM9 1dq
The proposal involved converting and extending existing buildings at 19 Malew Street and 20 Arbory Street, plus the yard between, into a luxury hotel with 16 suites, restaurant, cocktail bar, retail units, three apartments above the existing retail at No.
Click a button above to find applications similar to this one.
See how this application compares to similar ones — policies, conditions, and outcomes side by side.
The Planning Committee refused the application because it made no provision for parking staff, residents or guests' vehicles, leading to increased demand on already limited on-street and off-street pa…
Support in principle with conditions: due regard to archaeological potential consulting Manx Museum; confirm limestone facing for detailed application; detailed application to reflect principle approval.
Strongly support as it provides hotel for commercial sector without using open countryside land; notes parking snag but Policy PK/P/2 in draft plan makes provision; disturbed by archway alterations for vehicles.
Environmental Health, Manx National Heritage, and Disability Access Office provided conditional no objection responses with specific requirements for food hygiene, archaeological recording, and accessibility; DOT Highways objected due to lack of parking; public representations included objections on parking, heritage, and traffic plus limited support.
Key concern: No parking provision for 16-bedroom hotel in parking-constrained town centre
Department of Environment, Safety & Health
Conditional No ObjectionThe walls, floors, doors, windows, ceiling, woodwork, and all other parts of the structure of every food room shall... enable them to be effectively cleaned, and prevent... risk of infestation
Conditions requested: Food rooms walls, floors, doors, windows, ceiling, woodwork to enable effective cleaning and prevent infestation; Floor of food rooms surfaced with impervious durable material; Surfaces contacting food impervious to grease/fat/oil and easily cleaned; Shelves/service pipes fixed 1 inch clear of walls and 1 foot above floor; Cupboard units/counters fixed to prevent vermin harbourage, prefer mobile tables/shelves; Cooking/refrigeration equipment fixed clear of walls with access for cleaning, prefer movable equipment; Suitable ventilated food storage with refrigeration meeting Regulation 27 Food Hygiene (General) Regulations 1978; Suitable sinks for food/equipment washing with hot/cold water, draining platforms, stainless steel preferred; For no dishwasher: two sinks with draining or double bowl sink; with dishwasher: single sink; Suitable ventilation per Regulation 23 including extract for cooking appliances; Suitable lighting; Accommodation for clothing storage and drying not in food rooms unless lockers; Hand washing basins for food handlers with hot/cold water, near food rooms, in toilets; Sanitary accommodation per table for numbers accommodated, with ante-chamber ventilation; Refuse storage in sealed containers on impervious floor, ventilated separately; Intercept grease from drainage, no nuisance from effluvia/noise/vibration; Provision for chronically sick/disabled
Manx National Heritage
Conditional No ObjectionWe would strongly recommend that a record be made of the buildings prior to their demolition; any future detailed development proposals must include provision for developer-funded archaeological investigation
Conditions requested: Record be made of the buildings prior to their demolition; Developer-funded archaeological investigation and recording of areas affected by groundworks including re-profiling, footings, service trenches
Disability Access Office
Conditional No ObjectionConditions requested: Designated disabled parking: up to 200 spaces 5% min 3; over 200 4% plus 4; Hotel entrance accessible to unassisted wheelchair user; Reception counter section for wheelchair users; Disabled public toilet; disabled staff toilet if separate; Proportion of rooms generous for ambulant disabled; proportion adapted for wheelchair users; Lift sufficient for unassisted wheelchair user to enter/turn/use controls if multi-level; Retail entrance accessible, glass doors marked mid-height, door pull ≤20 Newtons or automatic; Aisle width for wheelchair manoeuvre; Serving counter section for wheelchair users; Apartment parking 5% unassigned for disabled if visitor parking provided; Primary entrance accessible to wheelchair user; Public sanitary facilities include disabled toilet; Public corridors wheelchair width unobstructed; Apartment primary entrance wheelchair accessible width; Lift if multi-level for wheelchair use
DOT Highways
ObjectionDoT Highways cannot accept a 16-bedroom luxury hotel in this town centre location, without making any provision, on - or off - site for the parking of cars