23 October 2025
Land Abutting Palace Road, Rear Of 25, Falcon Cliff Court, Douglas, Isle Of Man, IM2 4lz
AP250018 2491049B DEFA Planning Officer Appeal Statement
AP250018 2491049B Owner of 23 Falcon Cliff Court Appeal Statement
AP250018 2491049B Owner of 25 Falcon Cliff Court Appeal Statement
AP250018 2491049B Wilson Consulting on Behalf of the Applicant
Cabinet Office Statement of Case Invite
Within 30m of this property
Appeal against the refusal for erection of a new dwelling with associated parking and landscaping
Erection of a new dwelling with associated parking and landscaping
Installation of external doors and balconies, with internal works to create two residential units and offices, and mixed use as dwelling (Class 3.3) and offices (Class 2.1)
Creation of a parking area for four vehicles for hotel use
Erection of a dwelling
Erection of an extension to dwelling
Erection of a car port with balcony over, on side elevation
Appeal against refusal for the Construction of a sunken garage with access onto Palace Road, conversion of existing garage to kitchen and dining room with installation of front bay window at ground floor
Construction of a sunken garage with access onto Palace Road, conversion of existing garage to kitchen and dining room with installation of front bay window at ground floor
Erection of car port with balcony over
Alterations including thermal re-lining front and rear walls, installation of front bay window, uPVC rear porch and replacement window, and construction of sunken garage with access onto Palace Road
Approval in principle for erection of dwelling
Approval in principle for 3 self contained apartments and associated parking
Approval in principle for 3 self contained apartments and associated parking
Approval in principle for 6 single garages
Click a button above to find applications similar to this one.
See how this application compares to similar ones — policies, conditions, and outcomes side by side.
The original application for a new two-storey flat-roofed dwelling was refused by a Principal Planner on 13 May 2025 due to inappropriate scale/form harming the attractive Victorian streetscene along Palace Road (contrary to GP2(b),(c),(g) and EP42) and adverse impact on neighbour amenity at No.25 Falcon Cliff Court from overbearing scale 8.5-10m away (GP2(g), EP42). The appellant argued the streetscene is mixed modern/Victorian, the design mimics a garden fence with no overlooking, and it's on mixed-use zoned land. The inspector disagreed with the council's characterisation of a purely Victorian streetscene, found the modern design acceptable in the varied context, minimal bank/vegetation loss, no harm to Registered Hotel setting, and no significant amenity loss due to separation/distances. Highways had no objection. The appeal was allowed on 23 October 2025 subject to 11 conditions including materials, levels, landscaping, parking, drainage, and restrictions on future development.
Precedent Value
Demonstrates appeals can succeed by evidencing streetscene evolution and precise design responses to amenity concerns; distinguishes prior refusals on merits; prioritises current context over history in mixed urban areas.
Inspector: Brian J Sims BSc (Hons) CEng MICE MRTPI
