13 August 2025
Field 612727, Baldrine Road, Baldrine, Isle Of Man, IM4 6ee
Information in relation to Condition 7 of PA 23/00388/B and AP24/0052 detailing measures for landscaping including the boundary hedging, new sod banks and new tree and feature planting
Information in relation to Condition 6 of PA 23/00388/B and AP24/0052 detailing measures for the protection of trees
Information in relation to Condition 15 of PA 23/00388/B and AP24/0052 detailing tree root protection during installation of wastewater sewage pipes through Plot 7
Information in relation to Condition 10 of PA 23/00388/B and AP24/0052 detailing installation of wastewater sewage pipes through Plot 7
Information in relation to Condition 13 of PA 23/00388/B and AP24/0052 detailing external finishes of materials, roof, walls, windows, doors, garage doors and rainwater goods
Information in relation to Condition 12 of PA 23/00388/B and AP24/0052 detailing measures for the protection of the archaeological sites
Information in relation to Condition 14 of PA 23/00388/B detailing surface water drainage plan
Appeal against the refusal construction of seven detached houses and associated infrastructure
Construction of seven detached houses and associated infrastructure
Reserved matters application for erection of a dwelling on plot one addressing siting, internal layout, design, means of access, external appearance and landscaping (in association with 16/01139/A)
Creation of field access
Click a button above to find applications similar to this one.
See how this application compares to similar ones — policies, conditions, and outcomes side by side.
The original application was recommended for approval by the case officer but refused by the Planning Committee on 25 November 2024 for reasons including compromise of Strategic Reserve designation via access road, potential flooding exacerbation, lack of demonstrated housing need, insufficient archaeological mitigation, and highway safety impacts. The appellant argued the site has been zoned for residential development since 1982 with access through the Strategic Reserve acknowledged in successive plans, technical approvals from highways and drainage authorities, no need demonstration required for zoned land, and archaeological sites outside the redline with MNH non-objection. The inspector's inquiry on 15 April 2025 with site visit found the proposal compliant with zoning, access acceptable per Area Plan for the East, no unacceptable impacts on drainage, archaeology, highways or amenities, recommending allowance. The Minister accepted the recommendation on 13 August 2025, approving the appeal subject to detailed conditions.
Precedent Value
Confirms access through Strategic Reserve permissible for zoned adjacent sites if longstanding and technically approved; committees cannot override zoning/Area Plan Inspectors without evidence; technical reports essential on appeal. Future applicants should submit comprehensive consultee evidence early and cite full planning history.
