3 February 2026
Street Record, Bellevue Park, Peel, Isle Of Man, IM5 1uq
Appeal against the refusal for the Installation of 8 telegraph poles to provide fibre optic connectivity to 1-41 Bellevue Park and 1-17 Carmane Close
Installation of 8 telegraph poles to provide fibre optic connectivity to 1-41 Bellevue Park and 1-17 Carmane Close
Click a button above to find applications similar to this one.
See how this application compares to similar ones — policies, conditions, and outcomes side by side.
Peel Town Commissioners rebut the appeal against refusal of telegraph pole installations, citing non-compliance with planning policies and guidance favoring underground services; a residents' petition also opposes the poles.
Key concern: erection of telegraph poles will clutter the street scene and violate policies requiring underground services
Peel Town Commissioners
ObjectionThe erection of telegraph poles with overhead wiring will created a clutter the street scene and will be unsightly for a modern residential urban environment.; These applications do not comply with these Strategic Plan policy requirements.; These planning applications do not comply with the guidance provided by the Department of Infrastructure for constructing and installing highway infrastructure.
The original application PA25/90399/B for installation of 8 telegraph poles was refused by the Planning Committee on 13 October 2025 due to negative visual impact on the streetscene contrary to General Policy 2(b & c). The appellant argues the poles are necessary for fibre rollout, comply with policy, and benefits outweigh limited visual impact, citing prior approvals and national telecom strategies. The Council defends refusal citing visual harm in a pole-free residential area, pedestrian safety concerns, residential amenity impacts, and recent dismissed appeals for similar poles in Tromode estate. The inspector’s report analyses character/appearance (significant harm), pedestrian safety (no harm), and living conditions (no harm), recommending dismissal. Third party objections focus on access, visual impact, wildlife, and weather. No appeal outcome determined.
Precedent Value
Appeals for telegraph poles in established residential estates without prior poles/overhead lines likely to fail where they harm uncluttered streetscene character, per Tromode precedent; applicants must evidence underground infeasibility and minimise visual prominence.
